Date: 16th August 2017 at 8:20am
Written by:

The Missing ‘X` Factor

Using my own memory of Villa teams of the past, and my own experience in the coaching world, one thing has been continually nagging away at me about my beloved AVFC for a very long time now.

On-field Leadership.

If you assess the purchases that the club has made over the past year or so, we have signed countless individuals who have shown leadership qualities and/or been captains at their previous clubs. Steve Bruce has continued the trend of RDM last summer (Elphick, McCormack, Chester) with his own acquisitions of “tried and trusted leaders” such as Terry, Hourihane, Lansbury and Whelan.
Yet, when you watch the matches, not a soul seems to react in adversity to rally or cajole the troops! When we concede its just hands on hips or heads down and trudge back to the halfway line. Personally I yearn to see the players huddle up and see a senior player having a go at others! When did a Villa player get a booking for up-ending an opponent who was getting too much time on the ball?

Terry, for me, is an interesting case. He said all the right things on his arrival, yet he doesn`t seem to be showing that same passion on the pitch. Three games in and not a solitary tackle of note. No moments of anger as he points at someone who failed in their responsibilities. In fact, between them, I don`t think any of our defenders have had a booking for an overzealous tackle yet! Recent media reports suggested that he was still spending plenty of time back at Chelsea “to aid in his recovery.” I get the fact that he still leaves in/near London, but how can a club captain be spending recovery time away from his club while his teammates are there? I can only assume that he does so with the manager`s blessing. To me that sends a bad message.

This brings me to my main point. How many times have Villa (or any other club for that matter) purchased “leaders” and see them be successful? Our own John Terry developed into a leader at Chelsea, a club that he grew up with and played at for his whole career.

Look back at the great Villa teams of the 70`s and 80`s. Leaders like Mortimer, Evans, Rioch, Ross, Nicholl, McNaught. None of them were ‘bought for leadership.` They were integrated into the club, developed a passion and evolved as leaders. Even going to the 90`s, and 00`s, Townsend, Teale, Staunton, Mellberg, Laursen, Platt, Barry etc. all BECAME leaders as they grew into their AVFC careers. Although I do remember back in the late 70`s when the great Ron Saunders bought Tommy Craig and immediately installed him as captain – he was a disaster! Ron realized quickly that buying a ready-made leader didn`t work!

Leadership has many forms: vocal, physical, by example. Think back to the days when we were competing on an almost level playing field with Man Utd. Andy Townsend would crunch Roy Keane with a tackle early on every single time we played them. He was sending a message, making sure that Keane knew he was in for a game that day. We didn`t always beat them, but we never wiltedÂ…
So, where do we get those natural leaders in this current team, not just blokes who have done it in the past, but men who truly have a passion for this great club and are willing to put this team on their shoulders and fight? I`m stumped. There`s plenty of talk among the fans about the disruptive ones in the dressing room (Agbonlahor being the glaring example). Those types would never have survived in the times of those I`ve mentioned above, nor ironically would they have lasted ten minutes in John Terry`s Chelsea dressing roomÂ…



4 Replies to “Aston Villa: The Missing X Factor”

  • Our problem is we accept ‘lack lustre’ performances time after time, there are players who ‘do nothing of note’ yet play week in week out , the usual ‘they will come good’ etc etc , I wonder if our current and previous managers have been watching the same

  • Excellent article gmvillan and I agree a very important factor that is sadly lacking today.
    Clark was perhaps developing into that type of player – but we let him go. It’s not only
    the players though – it starts at the top and the last manager we had wi

  • Agreed DJ. JG had an ego and a certain brashness about him. It’s similar to what you see in Mourhino, Ferguson, Klopp, Wenger etc. They TRULY don’t care what others think and run their club on their own terms. The problem Villa have is that we’ve employed

Comments are closed.