Date: 27th December 2018 at 11:11am
Written by:

Player ratings from the The Villa away to Swansea forum match thread.. by Villan57.

Agree? Disagree? Use the player ratings widget below to give us your ratings.

Had to watch this on the red button but it’s a bit like watching it live as you don’t get 10 replays of every incident. Poor show really after recent weeks but the result was all that mattered today. My Player ratings.

Nyland: 7 Finally won us a game with a Penalty save, probably making him MOTM by default. Clean sheet.

Elmo: 5 Gave nothing going forwards and not much more defensively. I’m being generous, aren’t I?

Bree: 6 Thought he did ok certainly wasn’t the worst game he’s had.

Chester: 6 Not his best game but we kept them out so get an extra point

Hutton: 6 Giving him that as he set up the Goal, I nearly said the “A” word then.

Whelan: 4 Chased shadows most of the game, never got going,

McGinn: 5 probably his worst game, he’s set the bar high but wasn’t his day, missed a sitter as well.

Hourihane: 5 Gets that for his goal otherwise see Whelan.

El Ghazi: 4 Flattered to deceive, a point off for needlessly giving away a penalty.

Tammy: 5 Didn’t do enough for me, but never had a decent chance.

Bolasie:4 should have been subbed far earlier than he was for Albert. Looked as out of sorts as most of them to be fair.


Albert: 6 Came on did his job as he nearly always does.

Kodj and Barney not on long enough to rate. should have been on a lot sooner in my view.


Smith: 6 Probably our worst performance under him but we got the win despite it.

With thanks to Villan57

Click for the forum